Home · Blog

Wi-Fi Calling vs. VoIP: What Actually Separates Them

· VoiRelay · 1 view

voipwifi-calling

I used to treat "Wi-Fi calling" as one idea. If a call traveled over Wi-Fi, I figured the details underneath did not matter much. They do. Carrier Wi-Fi Calling is a feature on a cellular plan. A VoIP number is a separate internet phone service. That difference is why I built VoiRelay as its own low-cost U.S. number and voice service, not as an add-on to a carrier plan.

What carrier Wi-Fi Calling actually is

The major U.S. carriers describe Wi-Fi Calling as a feature of the mobile service I already pay for. AT&T says Wi-Fi calling — also known as Voice over Wi-Fi (VoWiFi) — lets a phone place calls and texts over a Wi-Fi network instead of the provider's cellular network, and that the feature can turn on automatically when the cellular signal is weak or unavailable. The call still uses the existing mobile number and the phone's built-in dialer. Verizon's Wi-Fi Calling FAQs treat it the same way: a built-in feature, billed according to the wireless plan. T-Mobile's Wi-Fi Calling page sits in the same family. The number on the SIM, the carrier account, and the native phone app stay in the middle of the call.

That is useful in a room with a weak cell signal and a solid Wi-Fi connection. It is also still a carrier feature. It depends on the plan and the phone supporting it, and it is tied to the cellular number I already have. It does not give me a second number, and it does not let me drop the carrier plan and keep the same service. If the Wi-Fi drops, the call may fall back to the cellular network. T-Mobile notes that this fallback can matter in particular outside the U.S., because a drop can switch the call onto a foreign cellular network.

AT&T also draws a line between that built-in feature and third-party apps, which are a different kind of internet calling and can run on devices that are not on a cell plan. That second category is closer to what I mean by VoIP.

What a VoIP number is

The FCC describes Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) as a technology for making voice calls over a broadband internet connection instead of a regular analog phone line. Some VoIP services only reach other people on the same service. Others can call regular telephone numbers. The FCC notes that a call can be placed from a computer, a special VoIP phone, or a traditional phone with an adapter, depending on the service, and that wireless hotspots in airports, parks, and cafes may be used to place a VoIP call.

A VoIP number, in the form I care about, is a real phone number that is not riding on a cellular SIM. It does not require a particular carrier's Wi-Fi Calling feature, and it does not have to be the same number as my cell line. The FCC's consumer guide even notes that a VoIP provider may let someone select an area code different from the one where they live. The service needs a working internet connection, which can be Wi-Fi, a wired connection, or another form of broadband. If the power is out or the internet is down, the FCC notes that some VoIP services do not work, and that the provider may not offer backup power.

That is the shape of what I built. VoiRelay is a low-cost U.S. phone number and voice service that works over Wi-Fi, from the web and from Android. I wrote about why I started it in an earlier post. I wanted a number I could use when I already had internet, without paying a carrier's price for a plan I barely needed in those moments, and without tying the number to a particular cellular account.

Coverage, outages, and 911

Both kinds of calling depend on a decent connection, and both have limits I take seriously.

Carrier Wi-Fi Calling can fill in a weak-signal room, as long as the Wi-Fi holds and the feature is available on the plan and the phone. When the Wi-Fi fails, the carrier side of the story is that the phone may try the cellular network instead. A VoIP call does not have that carrier handoff. If my internet drops, the call can drop with it. That is a trade-off I accepted when I decided to build around Wi-Fi and broadband rather than around a SIM.

Emergency calling is the limit I watch most closely. The FCC's guide to VoIP and 911 service is clear that internet-based 911 is handled differently from a regular telephone 911 call. A VoIP 911 call may not connect to the call center that serves the caller's current location, may not automatically transmit the caller's number or location, and may depend on a registered address being kept up to date. The service may not work during a power outage or when the internet fails. The FCC also notes that not all VoIP services connect directly to 911. I still keep a regular mobile phone for emergencies, and I have learned not to treat a Wi-Fi-only call as a complete substitute for a phone that can place a 911 call with a known location.

I have not tried to flatten carrier Wi-Fi Calling into the same 911 picture. It is still the carrier's call on an existing mobile number. The FCC's detailed 911 warnings I relied on here are the ones written for VoIP, and those are the limits that apply to the kind of service I built.

Why I built a separate service, not a carrier add-on

Carrier Wi-Fi Calling never solved the problem I actually had. It made my existing cell number work better in a poorly covered room. It did not give me a low-cost number of my own, and it did not change the fact that I was still paying for a traditional mobile plan just to keep a line. I wanted something that could live on the Wi-Fi I already use, from a browser or an Android phone, as its own U.S. number.

That is VoiRelay. It is a VoIP service, not a feature on a cell plan. The two can both travel over Wi-Fi and still be different products. I try to keep that distinction straight, because it is the whole reason I built the thing.

References

  1. What is Wi-Fi Calling and How Does it Work? – AT&T
  2. Wi-Fi Calling at Verizon FAQs
  3. Wi-Fi Calling from T-Mobile
  4. Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) – Federal Communications Commission
  5. Consumer Guide: Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) – Federal Communications Commission
  6. VoIP and 911 Service – Federal Communications Commission
  7. Why I Built a Cheap Phone Service That Works Over Wi-Fi – VoiRelay

Get notified when we launch

Leave your email and we'll let you know when VoiRelay is open. No account is created, and you won't be charged.

I agree that VoiRelay may email me once when the service launches. You can ask to be removed at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Wi-Fi Calling vs. VoIP: What Actually Separates Them · VoiRelay