Home · Blog

Why I Wanted a Cheap Second Phone Number

· VoiRelay · 1 view

second-phone-numbervoip

I wanted a second phone number long before I had a name for the product. The number on my cell plan was fine for family and friends. It was less fine for side work, project inboxes, and the kind of listing or callback I did not want tied to my personal line. I was not looking for a second phone to carry around. I was looking for a cheap second number I could keep separate, and I did not want to pay for another full carrier line to get it.

The usual options were still carrier options

One path is simply to add another line to a wireless account. That works, and it also means another monthly plan on top of the one I was already paying for. Cell service is not a small line item. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, in Consumer Expenditure Surveys data republished by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, reports that the average consumer unit spent $1,390 on cellular phone service in 2025. That is about $116 a month, and it is a household-style average, so it can cover more than one line. A 2026 Reviews.org roundup, using provider pricing data and a survey of 1,000 U.S. adults in October 2026, put the average Big Three postpaid plan (AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon) at $57.60 a month. Those are not the same measurement, but both matched what I was already feeling: a traditional cell plan is a real recurring cost, and a second one is not a small add-on.

Carriers also sell a second number that rides on the phone I already carry. Verizon's Second Number plan, for example, is $15 a month, or $10 a month as a perk on some myPlan Unlimited plans. It requires a Dual SIM capable device with an available eSIM, and it is still a Verizon line, with unlimited talk and text in the U.S., Mexico, and Canada, and with data supplied by the primary line. For someone who wants a second cellular number inside the same carrier relationship, that is a clear product. It was not what I wanted. I did not want to pay $10 or $15 a month, on top of a plan I already had, for a second number that was still tied to a particular carrier and a particular handset setup.

What I actually wanted

I wanted a number I could give out for work and projects without handing over the line I use for everything else. I wanted it to be inexpensive. I wanted it to work on a phone I already owned, and I did not want a second SIM just to keep that separation. A lot of the talking I needed to do was already happening in places with Wi-Fi. I wrote about that earlier, in why I built a cheap phone service that works over Wi-Fi. The same feeling applied here. If I already had an internet connection, I did not see why a second number had to look like a second cell plan.

Voice over Internet Protocol (VoIP) is the plain idea that got me there. The FCC describes VoIP as a technology for making voice calls over a broadband internet connection instead of a regular analog phone line, and notes that a call can be placed from a computer or a wireless phone, depending on the service. The FCC's consumer guide also notes that a VoIP provider may let someone select an area code different from the one where they live. That is a different shape than a second line on a cellular account. It is a number that lives on the internet.

That is the shape of VoiRelay. I built it as a low-cost U.S. phone number and voice service that works over Wi-Fi, from the web and from Android. I will not turn this post into a price sheet. For me, the product is a way to keep a second number without adding another carrier plan, and without paying a carrier add-on for the privilege of a second line on the same phone.

The trade-offs I accept

A VoIP second number is not a complete substitute for a cell plan, and I do not treat it as one. It needs a working internet connection. If the power is out or the internet is down, the FCC notes that some VoIP services do not work, and that the provider may not offer backup power. I still keep a regular mobile phone for the moments when Wi-Fi is not there.

Emergency calling is the other limit I take seriously. The FCC's guide to VoIP and 911 service is clear that internet-based 911 is handled differently from a regular telephone 911 call. A VoIP 911 call may not reach the call center that serves the caller's current location, may not automatically transmit the caller's number or location, and may depend on a registered address being kept up to date. The service may not work during a power outage or when the internet fails. I have learned not to ask a Wi-Fi number to do a job — like reaching 911 from an unknown location — that it may not be able to do. I still keep a mobile phone for that.

There are smaller trade-offs too. Some businesses and websites treat a VoIP number differently from a mobile line, especially when they send a login code by text. That is a separate issue, and it is one I ran into while building the service. A second VoIP number is, for me, a way to call and be called without mixing that traffic into my personal cell line. It is not something I count on as a stand-in for every use of a mobile number.

Why I still wanted one

The household spending figures, the average major-carrier plan prices, and Verizon's own second-number add-on all pointed me in the same direction. A second cellular line, or a $10 to $15 carrier add-on, was a lot to pay for the fairly simple thing I wanted: a number I could keep apart from my personal one. A low-cost VoIP number that works over Wi-Fi I already use felt like the more straightforward response.

That is what I built VoiRelay to be. I wanted a cheap second phone number, and I wanted it to live on the internet rather than on another plan from a cell company.

References

  1. Expenditures: Cellular Phone Service: All Consumer Units (CXU270102LB0101M) – FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Expenditure Surveys)
  2. The State of Consumer Media Spending 2026 – Reviews.org
  3. Second Number plan FAQs – Verizon
  4. Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) – Federal Communications Commission
  5. Consumer Guide: Voice Over Internet Protocol (VoIP) – Federal Communications Commission
  6. VoIP and 911 Service – Federal Communications Commission
  7. Why I Built a Cheap Phone Service That Works Over Wi-Fi – VoiRelay

Get notified when we launch

Leave your email and we'll let you know when VoiRelay is open. No account is created, and you won't be charged.

I agree that VoiRelay may email me once when the service launches. You can ask to be removed at any time. See our Privacy Policy.

Why I Wanted a Cheap Second Phone Number · VoiRelay